Blog – old
The Five Best Strengths Assessments Compared
5 evidence-based strengths assessments for trainers, facilitators and coaches - VIA, CliftonStrengths, Strengths Profile, High5 and metaFox, side by side: what each one measures, the flavour of each, and when I actually reach for which.
Fifteen years. Five assessments.
I took my first strengths assessment back in 2010, studied them throughout my Master of Applied Positive Psychology in 2015-2017, and explored the most recent one in 2025. Every one of them showed me something the others had missed.
So when a trainer or a coach asks me which strengths assessment they should use, I know how many questions are underneath that one.
There are a lot of strengths surveys out there. They all promise clarity and the best insights, and it is tricky to work out which one fits the context you are working in, or the person in front of you.
I have used these tools across workshops, with my own teams, in coaching, and on myself.
In this article I set them out side by side, so you can skip the time usually spent on trial and error and go straight for the one that suits you best.
If you are working with strengths as a trainer or a coach, a strengths assessment will (hopefully) be an important part of your toolbox. If you are not yet familiar with why working with strengths in workshops is so powerful, check out this article.
If you are already using one, here you can discover how it compares with the others. And if you are still searching for the best tool for your practice, this article should give you an answer.
The big challenge with strengths assessments: how do I choose the right one? So let’s dive in.
Still working out the why and the how of a strengths-based approach? You can discover many more tips and tools in the free ebook, The Strengths Toolkit for Trainers and Coaches.
Two disclaimers before we start.
First: assessment providers change their tiers, names and prices often, so check the current details yourself before you rely on them. All pricing here is what I found on the providers’ own sites, or paid when I took the tests myself.
Second: I have a lot of hours with these tools (and a master’s in applied positive psychology), and what I bring to this comparison is my own experience of working with them extensively - a subjective impression, not a verdict on the ultimately best tool.
What all five have in common
They are all self-reporting tools. You answer questions about yourself, and the tool gives you back a structured, ranked picture. That makes every one of them a mirror, not a measurement - a good place to start a conversation, never the whole truth about a person. Make that clear, and say it out loud to the people you work with. With that in mind, the tool does its job well, but should not be taken as an absolute truth.
There is real value in combining several of these, as each gives you a slightly different angle and list of strengths (though not all at once, as that would be overwhelming). The whole point of working with strengths is not to discover and admire them, but to put them to use.
That is why, if you are taking several surveys, spacing them out works far better than taking them all at the same time. Ideally you take one, work with it, and come back to a different tool a few months or even years later for a fresh angle. I have done all five myself, the first back in 2010 and the last in 2025, and each one gave me something new.
Now, here are the five, and what makes each one feel different in practice.
CliftonStrengths (by Gallup)
What it is: the well-known one, formerly StrengthsFinder. 34 talent themes grouped into four domains. You get your top 5 by default, with the option to unlock the full 34.
How long it takes: about 30 minutes in one sitting. It is timed, with 20 seconds per question, so it is best taken when you are alert and undisturbed.
The flavour: corporate, concise, action-oriented. The theme names are sticky and easy to say out loud, which is exactly why they travel so well around a team. It is the one most organisations already recognise, so it walks into a business room without explaining itself.
Fee: paid. Gallup’s current prices on their own store:
- Top 5 access code: $24.99 (and if you later want the whole picture, the upgrade to all 34 is $49.99, so you are not locked out by starting small)
- CliftonStrengths 34 bought outright: $59.99
- Role-specific reports: Managers, Leaders and Sales $49.99 each, Students $24.99
Top 5 or the full 34: the Top 5 gives you your five strongest themes with insights and action items. The 34 ranks every theme and adds your blind spots, your lesser strengths, and how your themes spread across the four domains. Go for the full 34 straight away - that wider picture is what makes it useful with teams, and upgrading later costs $74.98 against $59.99 outright.
One thing to know about the book, so you do not waste money: buying the assessment does not get you the book; it works the other way round. A new sealed copy of StrengthsFinder 2.0 has a single-use code in the back that unlocks the Top 5. The trap is second-hand copies, where the code has usually been used already. So if you want the test, buy the code from Gallup. If you want the book, buy it new and sealed.
Certification: Gallup does have a certification for coaches and facilitators. It is not a must - you can use CliftonStrengths with people and teams without it. What it gives you is the Gallup-Certified Strengths Coach title, a place in their coaches directory, and their proprietary coaching materials.
Science: built on Gallup’s large, long-running research programme into talent themes, drawn from decades of workplace data. CliftonStrengths is among the most researched of the five, but almost all of that research is done internally by Gallup, with a strong focus on corporate settings and performance.
Where is it best to use? I reach for it with teams, especially in a corporate or business environment. It is my favourite for team work, precisely because it is so concise and business-minded. The short, memorable language makes it easy for team members to remember each other’s strengths and trade on them, which is where the real value of a team session lives. In that sense the report plays a little like a set of strengths cards - quick, shared, usable - though it goes deeper than a deck.
VIA Character Strengths
What it is: 24 character strengths, from a free 96-question survey. Over 40 million people have taken it.
The flavour: humanistic and values-led. This is about character - who you are at your best - rather than workplace performance. It is warm, reflective, and free (though the free version gives you only the ranked list; you need the paid report for anything in-depth). A fairly soft, gentle introduction to the whole topic of strengths.
Fee: the ranked list of your 24 is free. Paid reports add depth: $19 for the Top 5 Report, and $49 for the flagship Total 24 Report. Check their website for team and youth options and for any current discounts. Worth being honest here: the free report gives quite scarce information, and even the paid one is less detailed than most of the others. But it is also one of the cheapest, and it has solid research and a strong framework behind it.
Feedback from others: VIA does have a peer-rating form, but it sits in the research literature rather than in the reports you can buy, so in practice what you get here is self-report only.
Science: the strongest, most openly published research base of the five, from Peterson and Seligman’s VIA classification of character strengths. VIA is the most solidly evidence-based of the five tools, and the only one with a large body of independent, peer-reviewed research behind it. It measures character, not work performance.
Where is it best to use? I reach for it in NGOs, with first-timers, and whenever a free resource matters. No barrier, no cost, no corporate framing to get past. I use it with anyone stepping into strengths gently for the first time, and whenever it is important to have something free that people can use for themselves. The softest, most human entry point of the group.
Free survey at viacharacter.org
Strengths Profile (now Skills Discovery, Cappfinity)
What it is: the most extensive of all five in this article. It has the longest list of strengths and one of the richest reports, alongside metaFox’s focused report. It sorts strengths into the familiar four groups: realised, unrealised, learned skills and weaknesses.
A quick note on the name: the rebrand went live on 20 April 2026, and Strengths Profile is now Skills Discovery. They kept the same framework and renamed the umbrella. Do not get confused by the fact that they now call it skills - in reality it is still a strengths-focused survey, built on the same model (metaFox also looks into the same distinction, learned skills versus natural strengths).
And a note on the count, because it has moved: the new Skills Discovery measures 80, scored on the same three dimensions of performance, energy and use, and sorted into the same four quadrants. The older 60-strength products have not gone away - they are still on sale alongside it, so both numbers are live at once. The Expert Profile now goes up to the full 80, and you can still choose the 60 version if you prefer.
Everything in this section is accurate as of November 2026, while the transition is still bedding in. Names, counts and tiers have been moving: the Expert Profile now goes up to 80, learned behaviours are now called learned skills, and the 60 version is still available alongside the new one. Please check their site yourself before you rely on any of it.
The flavour: deep and comprehensive. Its standout is the distinction between strengths you have and ones you only think you have - the learned skills you are good at but that quietly drain you. Very few tools surface that in this way, so it remains one of my favourites.
Fee: there is a free Starter Profile (limited: your top 3 realised strengths, 3 unrealised, 2 learned skills and 1 weakness). Then the paid Introductory Profile (up to 21 skills, in a 60 or 80 version) and the Expert Profile (up to the full 80), plus Leader, Team and Group profiles.
This is the one tool in this article where I cannot give you a price. Their store shows prices only once you are inside it, they vary by region, and they are quoted excluding VAT, so there was no current figure I could verify well enough to print here. The same goes for the exact names of their accreditation levels and their 2026 technical manual, which I could not check on their public pages. That is what we know, and I would rather say so than guess. Go to the store directly for the live numbers.
Certification: Cappfinity has an accreditation programme (a Level 1 Strengthener course and a Level 2 Accreditation). It is not required to buy or use profiles - it just helps you debrief well.
Science: science-based, built by positive psychology researchers Alex Linley and Nicky Garcea over more than a decade of research, with a published technical manual, now reissued for 2026 as a Skills Discovery technical manual.
Where is it best to use? My deep-dive tool, and my second choice in coaching. When I want to go furthest into someone’s strengths, this is the one. There are two honest reasons why metaFox is usually my first choice in coaching. The first is that metaFox brings in feedback from others much more strongly. The second is that Strengths Profile is so comprehensive it can overwhelm, and it can be harder to turn all that detail into clear next steps.
High5
What it is: a free test giving your top 5 from a list of 20 strengths across four domains.
How long it takes: around 120 questions on a simple agree-to-disagree slider, untimed - about 15 to 20 minutes. It is the easiest and most user-friendly of the five to actually sit and take, a relaxed experience. Great if you want to avoid putting people under any pressure - use it in a relaxed retreat setting rather than a formal event. From my perspective, that ease is a real selling point for High5.
The flavour: fast, light, immediately usable. No certified interpreter needed. It makes a point that your lower strengths are not weaknesses, just not where your energy sits, which is a nice, encouraging note to pass on.
Fee: free top 5. The paid report is $29 and adds your full ranked 20, development detail, watch-out areas, best-partner profiles and career applications. Team packages are priced per person.
Feedback from others: worth knowing that High5 does this too. The paid report includes a one-time 360, and peer feedback is a feature on their platform, so this is another tool here that brings other people’s view of you into the picture.
Science: grounded in positive psychology and refined on a large user dataset, with a lighter published research base than the academic tools.
Where is it best to use? I recommend it to people who want to explore on their own. It suits someone who wants to take something themselves, at their own pace, and appreciates the follow-up emails, nudges and reminders that keep the results alive after the test.
metaFox Strengths Discovery
What it is: a visual, browser-based survey built specifically for coaching, across 16 strength roles. It produces a Strengths Report designed as the basis for a coaching conversation.
The flavour: coaching-first and refreshingly light on the client. The graphic survey feels human, and the report is built to open a conversation rather than bury the person in data. What sets metaFox apart is that it is designed to bring in feedback from others: alongside your own self-assessment, metaFox is rolling out the ability to invite people to give you strengths-based feedback, so the report can show just your own answers, just others’ feedback, or the two combined. Few other tools build this into the core report, and it is a really valuable direction.
Fee: currently free. As of now, the Strengths Discovery app is 100% free - for individuals and coaches alike. As a coach, you simply send your client the link; they take the survey, view their results and export a PDF report to bring to the session. metaFox does sell other coaching tools - the Stronger You cards, the Strengths Compass and the wider metaFox.online platform - and the survey pairs really nicely with those, but the Strengths Discovery survey itself costs nothing.
Use metaFox discount code TRAINERSTOOLBOX10 to get 10% off your first purchase of any of their physical products, and a free month of metaFox.online.
A quick note so nobody trips over the metaFox range: Strengths Discovery is the survey, Stronger You is the 52-card deck, the Strengths Compass is a separate reference card, and metaFox.online is the online platform that holds these and many other coaching tools together. Four different things.
Science: the newest of the five, and rebuilt from the item content up. metaFox sampled the item pools of five leading strengths instruments, kept the behavioural themes that recurred across them, and used that to build the current 16-domain model, developed with scientific guidance from the Department of Psychological Diagnostics at Ruhr University Bochum and published in full in their research report.
Where is it best to use? My go-to in coaching. I love that the report does not overload the client and steps straight into implementation. You get the most from metaFox when you couple it with an actual coaching conversation, which is exactly what it is made for.
You can also listen to podcast episode 37, with Tobi from metaFox and me.
What the questions actually look like in each survey
One more practical difference worth knowing, because it changes how the test feels to take. Some ask you to score yourself on statements, one has a this-or-that format, and two use sliders.
- CliftonStrengths: paired statements, this or that. You see two statements and choose which is more you, and how strongly, on a 5-point spectrum with a neutral middle, 20 seconds each. Gallup’s own example: “I read instructions carefully” versus “I like to jump right into things.”
- VIA: single statements you rate on a 5-point scale, from very much like me to very much unlike me. 96 of them.
- Strengths Profile: you rate statements, and each strength is scored on three angles - how well you do it, how much you use it, and how energising it is. That third angle, energy, is what separates a real strength from a learned skill.
- High5: around 120 statements on a simple agree-to-disagree slider.
- metaFox: the most visual. Instead of linear scales, you place a marker on a two-dimensional field, a kind of coordinate axis, which feels more intuitive and less like a wall of text.
Five tools, side by side
| Tool | Strengths measured | Cost | Style | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CliftonStrengths | 34 themes (top 5) | Paid | Corporate, concise, memorable | Teams, business settings |
| VIA | 24 character strengths | Free (paid reports) | Humanistic, values-led, gentle | First-timers, NGOs, free resource |
| Strengths Profile / Skills Discovery | 80 skills (60 version still available) | Free profile + paid | Deep, comprehensive | Going deepest into strengths |
| High5 | 20 (top 5) | Free (paid report) | Fast, light, user-friendly | Self-guided exploration |
| metaFox Strengths Discovery | 16 strength roles | Free (platform for coaches) | Visual, coaching-first, feedback from others | Coaching conversations |
So which one should you choose?
Please take this guidance lightly. It is based on my own experience and impression of these tools, and my knowledge of them, but it is very far from fact. Each of these tools will do a great job for each of these use cases - with teams, with individuals, and in coaching. You can also pick based on what is available to you, what is convenient, and which brand you like. Match the tool to the situation, and to the style you want in the room.
- Working with a team, or in a corporate setting? CliftonStrengths. Concise, recognised, and easy for people to remember and use with each other. Secondary choice: metaFox.
- Someone new to strengths, or a gentler, more human context like an NGO? VIA. Free, warm, no barrier to entry. Secondary choice: High5, simple and user-friendly.
- Coaching one to one? metaFox. Built for the conversation, brings in feedback from others, and does not overwhelm. Secondary choice: Strengths Profile, for the deepest dig.
- Someone who wants to explore independently? High5. Fast, free at the top level, with follow-up to keep it alive.
And remember that you don’t have to pick only one. Taking two or three, with enough time to digest each, is definitely valuable, because each uses a slightly different vocabulary and surfaces something the others miss.
One thing to say to anyone taking a strengths survey
Whichever survey you use, for yourself or your participants, please make this point clearly: the strengths on that list are not your only strengths. You almost certainly have many more talents and capabilities than any test will show. Self-reflection and asking others for feedback are how you find the rest.
And remember, these surveys lean into your self-perception a lot. They are not an absolute truth - just a good place to start reflecting and to pick up new perspectives on yourself. Used that way, they are a gift.
But when working with strengths, there is also an interesting trap to keep in mind: a strength can be overused, and when it is, it starts to work against the person. I have written up a practical model for keeping strengths in balance separately, in Strengths Overused (and there is a podcast episode on it too).
Assessments are just one route into strengths. If you would rather open the conversation without a test, there are other practical ways in:
- Questions to uncover strengths
- Strengths cards
- Activities to work with strengths - and you can already get five of them as a free 5-day email series, one activity a day.
Want to work with strengths more deeply?
If you want to go into strengths in a deep, experiential way, I facilitate The Inner Journey in Italy - a three-day experience of working with images, emotions and strengths, with day three given entirely to strengths.
And choosing and using tools like these is exactly the kind of thing we work through together in Trainers Conversations, my year-round community of trainers and facilitators.
Curious but unsure if it is the right fit? Get in touch and we can work out together whether it is.
So, which of these assessments will you put next into someone’s hands, and what will you do with the result?
About Mirna Šmidt
Trainer & facilitator with 18+ years of experience. Founder of Trainers Toolbox & Happiness Academy. On a mission to help trainers create deep, science-based learning experiences that actually stick. Let's connect on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mirnasmidt/
View all posts by Mirna Šmidt